Hearth Buyers Guide Banner

The Complete Hearth Buyer’s Guide

Are you considering purchasing a fireplace, insert or stove? You’ve come to the right place! We’ve put together the complete guide that answers the most common questions. We will define what a fireplace, insert and stove are. Go over their different applications and when they should be used. Then, we’ll walk you through the steps to buying a hearth product, from sizing to pre-install requirements.

The Differences Between Hearth Types

Fireplace / Zero Clearance

Typically used in new construction or remodels, these fireplaces usually have:

  • Metal Louvers or Grills top and bottom
  • Glass Doors that fit inside
  • Chimney exterior or chase is constructed from wood and finished with siding or other materials to match the house
  • Top of chimney or chase has round metal chimney pipe or square metal cover that is visible

Insert / Masonry

Typically found in older homes, these inserts usually have:

  • Faced with brick
  • Opening has no metal within the opening
  • Chimney Exterior typically constructed of brick
  • Top of chimney has square or rectangular flue tile or cap

Stove / Free-standing

Can be used in most applications, usually requires a hearth pad:

  • Can see all sides of stove
  • Vent pipe visible in room
  • Very Flexible in its venting application

Why is This Important

The venting requirements for each type of hearth product is specific, and drastically different. Not every install scenario is suited for each type of hearth product, this can become the limiting factor for which type of hearth product can be installed in your scenario.

Venting Scenarios

This is best described through photos and drawings. We will refer to the drawings below to explain this section.

Types of Fuel

Wood

Benefits: Natural and available. Wood is a good way to supplement the use of your furnace while helping to drive the cost of heating your home down.
Fire Characteristics: Active and robust with steady rolling flames.
Fire Starting: Paper and kindling makes for an easy start. With added features in some wood hearth products such as Automatic Combustion Control (ACC) starting is simple.
Type of Heat: Convective + Radiant. Adding more wood immediately increases convective heat while adding to a strong and steady radiant heat at the same time.
Fuel Storage & Handling: Wood does best when stored in a dry area. A cord of wood is stacked 4’x4’x8’. An average home around 1,500sqft will require somewhere between 2-4 cords a year to keep warm.

Gas

Benefits: Convenient, Clean, Simple. Quickly turn on the fire with a snap of a switch or an adjustment of a thermostat. Most hearth products also for adjustments in flame height and fire intensity.
Fire Characteristics: Consistent, decorative and controllable. With some gas hearth products, you select the media and intensity of the fire.
Fire Starting: Simple. Operate through a flip of a switch or click of a remote. It’s very easy.
Type of Heat: Convective + Radiant.
Fuel Storage & Handling: Either through a pipeline (Natural Gas) or a Tank (Liquid Propane).

Pellet / Corn

Benefits: Clean burning and consistent. Pellets are considered affordable and renewable.
Fire Characteristics: Active and robust. Fully adjustable fire, from an inch high to a powerful 10 inch.
Fire Starting: Controlled by an automatic thermostat and temperature controls. You just need to keep the hopper full of pellets.
Type of Heat: Convective. Relying on air being blown through a heat exchanger and out into your home.
Fuel Storage & Handling: Pellets normally come in bags, typically around 40lbs. A 1,500 sq. ft. home usually requires 2-4 tons per season.

Types of Heat

Convection

This type of heat is fast acting, and easily achieved. Convection heat is when you use a heat source to heat the air and distribute it. Think of a blow dryer, a blow dryer uses a fan to pull air over a superheated coil and forces it in a particular direction. A fan in your fireplace or mounted to your stove is generally how these units achieve the convection, always nice to have, they are most necessary in a home where airflow is limited and there is no other way to circulate the air.

Radiant

This type of heat is the most long lasting and is generally considered to be more desirable. Radiant heat is that comfortable, “toasty” feeling heat that we all associate with a wood stove, it is achieved by warming up items within a room, which then in turn radiate the heat into the air, which is circulating naturally. If the area in which you are looking at installing a hearth appliance has good air circulation, heating radiantly is always the ideal situation. However, I think it’s always ideal to have the option of a fan, for those extra cold winter days where it’s nice to heat the air up while waiting for the home to absorb the heat.

Terminology

Now that you can “talk the talk”, let’s move forward, and explore some of the qualifying attributes of a hearth unit, to dial in what is most appropriate for you and your home. One of the first things you’ll want to establish is whether or not you’d like this unit to be an effective heater or not. There are a few variables that are going to determine its heating ability, let’s go over them.

BTUs

AKA British Thermal Unit

The most commonly associated metric for a unit’s ability to heat. It is defined as “the amount of heat required to raise the temperature of one pound of water by one-degree Fahrenheit.”

Hearth appliances come in a variety of BTU ranges, from as little as 5,000 to 120,000 BTU’S. This unit of measure is used to determine how big of an area the hearth appliance will heat.

Questions to Ask Dealers

When talking about hearth appliances such as Fireplace, Stoves or Inserts there are many qualifying factors to consider to determine what type of appliance will work best for you.

What Type of Glass is Used?

Tempered

Tempered glass is “heat reflective”, or it is a poor conductor of heat. This is usually found in hearth appliances with lower BTU’S. Tempered glass has a thermal shock point (will break from too much heat) around 500 degrees Fahrenheit.

Ceramic

Ceramic glass is far and away the superior of the two, and here’s why; ceramic glass is like copper for electricity, it lets the heat flow with very little resistance. Ceramic glass’s shock point is nearly 5000 degrees Fahrenheit!

What Material is the Hearth Made of?

Steel

Steel stoves heat up very quickly, cool off relatively quickly, and radiate intense heat while they are in operation. They are rugged, durable, and are the most common on the market.

Cast Iron

Cast iron stoves take a bit longer to heat up, cool off relatively slowly, and strong heat while they are in operation. These stoves typically have a more traditional, decorative look to them.

Soapstone

There are a variety of companies out there that are building stoves out of Soapstone, a stone that is very similar to granite, but has properties that allow it to hold heat effectively for long periods of time. These stoves take a bit longer to heat up, they radiate soft, comfortable heat while they are in operation, and take hours and hours to cool down after the fire has gone out. Soapstone stoves have a variety of styles and looks from contemporary, to classy traditional.

Your Heating Needs

Heating Area

Almost all manufacturers want to tell you exactly how much area in square footage a unit is able to heat and will advertise this metric for ease of buying. It is a very loose guideline to gauge how effective a unit will be at heating your home. Cubic footage, and air changes per hour are a much truer profile of your home, however, who knows that stuff? We always recommend to go a tad bigger than the ratings say, due to the fact that, in reality, a larger unit offers a larger spectrum of heat, and doesn’t need to be run at maximum capacity at all times.

Fans

Do you need a fan? Fans are available on almost all units.

EPA Certified

For wood hearth appliances this is crucial. An EPA Certified wood burning fireplace is really more of a wood stove that is certified to be installed into a wall. These are designed to be effective heaters, and are sealed boxes that you burn wood in. The combustion air is pulled from a dedicated duct so the pressure of the home isn’t lowered, and air that you’ve worked hard to heat isn’t burned and sent up the chimney.

B-Vent vs Direct Vent

This is especially important when dealing with gas hearth products.

B-Vent Technology

This was the first generation of gas fireplaces, it is essentially the same technology as wood fireplaces operate with, an open-faced fireplace that pulls room air for combustion, and exhausts out of a vertical chimney. On some units there is the option of an outside air source to equalize pressure in the firebox and assist with the draft.

Direct Vent Technology

This is the modern standard for gas fireplaces. Direct Vent Technology is a method of venting a fireplace that involves a special type of pipe (Co-Axial), essentially this is a pipe inside of another pipe, typically a 4” pipe inside of a 7” pipe, or a 5” pipe inside of an 8” pipe. These pipes are sealed from one another and perform opposite actions. The interior pipe acts as the exhaust, and the exterior pipe acts as the intake. Almost every direct vent fireplace is a sealed box, and all of the combustion air is pulled from the outside, burned with the fire, and expelled as exhaust through the interior pipe of the chimney. There are multiple benefits to this style of fireplace venting; the fireplace is pulling air from outside to burn, rather than burning air that is already warm, keeping the warm air inside of the home, and second, since you are not burning room air, you are not lowering the pressure of the house, which means that you vastly diminish the amount of outside (cold) air infiltration into the home. These style fireplaces also have the ability to vent either horizontally or vertically, with flexibility in each scenario. Gas fireplace inserts also use this technology with their venting, although, instead of using a rigid co-axial pipe, they use two separate flexible aluminum pipes (co-linear) to vent.

Look at you! You’re becoming a pro! Now that you’ve got a pretty solid understanding of the different types of hearth units, and what they might be good for, let’s break it down a little farther and explore the different style options.

Design Elements of Hearth Products

We’ve all seen that fireplace or stove that was just absolutely jaw dropingly gorgeous, whether it was in Old Faithful Inn, in Yellowstone, or in the New York Museum of Modern Art, these units create a statement. There are many styles and designs to consider and finding the one that fits your taste just takes a bit of searching.

Whether it’s a gas fireplace or a wood fireplace, there are a few key styles that are really hot right now. Let’s jump in and look at a few of them.

Traditional / Square

The traditional fireplace, this is a fireplace that is usually quite square in shape with the height dimension very similar to its width. The panels inside (called refractories) are typically made from either brick material, or stone. There is a traditional log burner on the inside, and either an arched face or a clean, craftsman style facing given to it. These units are very popular, and account for the majority of fireplaces installed today.

Contemporary / Modern / Linear / Rectangle

Modern fireplaces have grown in popularity almost exponentially in the past few years. The rectangular shape provides a sleek and contemporary look that sets a room off like nothing else. These style fireplaces become the centerpiece for the area they’re installed in and have the ability to transform a room from dull and sterile, to chic and impressive. Their media ranges from shattered glass fragments for the flame to rise out of, to modern sculptures inside of the firebox, to polygonal shapes to give a super modern feel.

Transitional

Transitional fireplaces are some of the most style flexible units out there. They can add a modern touch to a traditionally decorated room or suggest a classic feel in a contemporary design. These can be slim rectangular modern shaped fireplaces, with a traditional log set inside of them, or a square traditionally shaped fireplace with a classic log set, and a touch of crushed glass on the floor, and reflective black panels on the inside to give it a modern feel. There is such a spectrum of options here that it’s really possible to be as modern or as classic as you like.

Custom

There are some absolutely amazing people out there who are designing and engineering fireplaces. From circular gas fireplaces, to ceilings that are fireplaces, literally if you are looking for something off the wall, and specific, it can be done. Just have your pocket book ready, custom units are beautiful and one of a kind, but certainly not cheap.

Stoves

Not to be forgotten, stoves have not entirely ignored the need for design elements and style. There are a number of manufacturers out there that have developed simply beautiful freestanding stoves on both the traditional and modern front. Europe has been very progressive in the development of gorgeous modern wood stoves, and classic style stoves are getting better and better by the year. From stainless steel pellet stoves, to circular, spinning wood stoves, there’s quite a variety of styles and designs in the world of stoves.

Brands That Matter / Don’t Matter

We’ve learned about what kind of fireplaces there are, which ones are best for which situations, and what kind of styling there is available. Maybe now we know what we want, but how do we really know if it’s any good? It seems like there’s a million manufacturers out there, what’s worth buying and what’s just not worth the time of day can be tough to decipher. Let’s explore the main brands that you may encounter: (Disclaimer – there are many other good brands than what is mentioned below, this is just a sampling of some of the larger brands that are worth exploring).

Large Brands

Quadra-Fire

Largest manufacturer of wood stoves in the world. Quality products, great warranty, good performance.

Heat N Glo

Inventor of Direct Vent technology, industry standard in gas fireplaces, great products, good performance.

Heatilator

Been in business for over 80 years, a builder’s favorite, there are more Heatilator fireplaces installed than any other brand, good warranty, acceptable performance.

Superior

Value brand fireplaces, been in business for 30+ years, basic units, acceptable performance.

Napolean

Value brand fireplaces, manufacturer of many products other than their hearth line, acceptable performance/product.

Montigo

Wide range from value brand to custom, imported fireplaces, acceptable performance/product.

Boutique Brands

Hearthstone

High quality, reasonably priced, fantastic products, great performance (Highly recommended).

Kozy Heat

High quality, reasonably priced, high end products, fantastic performance (Highly recommended).

Mendota

High end products, highly customizable, mid-high price range, great performance, great products.

Stuv

High end stoves, mid-high price range, great performance, great products.

Custom Brands

Ortal

Israeli Made, large fireplaces, high end price range, good selection.

Stellar

American Made, literally will design anything you want, fantastic selection of “production style customs”, fair price, excellent product.

Davinci

American Made, very large company, high price, great product.

Brands to Avoid

Englander/Vogelzang

Cheap metal, light weight, poor performance, poor factory support/warranty.

US Stove

Cheap metal, chincy, poor performance, poor warranty.

Breckwell

Cheap components, poor warranty, tolerable performance.

What to Expect for Costs

So now we’ve gone over just about all of the staples of the hearth shopping world, but we still haven’t talked about price! How much does this stuff cost?! Since there is such a range on each of these products, and services, we will do our best to find a fair number on what to expect:

Entry Mid High Avg Install Cost Avg Venting Cost Total Avg Cost
Gas Stove 1,649 3,029 3,959 450 600 3,929
Pellet Stove 1,999 2,699 4,239 500 400 3,879
Wood Stove 1,599 2,887 4,659 600 1,100 4,748
Gas Insert 2,585 3,407 5,041 450 400 4,528
Pellet Insert 2,618 3,183 3,978 500 600 4,360
Wood Insert 1,939 3,227 3,989 600 800 4,452
Gas Fireplace 1,119 2,839 5,400 450 400 3,969
Wood Fireplace 2,567 2,765 5,995 600 1,100 5,476

These costs are rough estimates. Pricing will depend on your particular situation, and what is required for installation, how much venting is needed, and what options are chosen to be included with the unit.

Conclusion

If you’ve made it this far, you’ve come a long way! Great job, hopefully you’ve learned some valuable information on what it takes to purchase a fireplace. An educated shopper is always going to make a better decision and be happier in the end. Now’s the fun part, get out there and use this new knowledge to find yourself that fireplace or stove you’ve been wanting!!

Stay warm, friends!